The subject of student visas aggravates me as much as illegal immigration (although we’re finally getting some great news on that front).
Why? “What’s the problem with student visas?” you might ask. For most, the topic probably conjures up images of foreign exchange students coming to the U.S. to experience life here and return home to spread the news about what a great place the U.S. is and to help spread our value system around the world. Or maybe you envision students coming here for an education that can be put to work back home in some underdeveloped country, helping to raise living standards there. But the reality of the situation is nothing like this. The student visa program boils down to money. It’s a system designed to suck trade dollars back into the U.S. economy and to prop up inflated tuitions.
Let’s begin with some data. Here are the statistics for non-immigrant visas issued from 2011 through 2015. (The data for 2016 is not yet available.) Student visas are primarily “F” visas. “M” visas are for vocational students. Taken together, they totaled nearly 700,000 in 2015. These are “non-immigrant” visas, but don’t be fooled. A large percentage of these students receive immigrant visas (leading to permanent status) almost automatically upon graduation.
Where do these students come from? About 280,000 came from mainland China. 75,000 came from India. 28,000 came from Saudi Arabia. 27,000 came from South Korea. 17,600 came from Vietnam. An equal number came from Mexico. 17,000 came from Japan. The rest are spread across the remaining nations of the world. The significance of this list will be discussed later.
To get an idea of what the student visa program is really about, take a look at this web site, which provides information for foreign students for how to apply:
What it boils down to is this: you have to explain why you want to study in the U.S. and, more importantly, you have to prove that you can pay for it. There’s no student loan program here, at least not through U.S. agencies. If you can get scholarship money from your native country, fine, but regardless of how you get the cash, you have to be able to pay your way. You must also declare your intent to return to your home country when you’re finished with your studies. But that’s a formality, one easily skirted when you actually get your degree.
In 2015, over 677,000 “F” visas were issued. 223,000 applicants were refused. In other words, about three quarters of all applicants are accepted.
Now, let’s take a look at some interesting findings about the student visa program published in a study by the Brookings Institution in 2012. Here’s the link:
“From 2008 to 2012, 85 percent of foreign students pursuing a bachelor’s degree or above attended colleges and universities in 118 metro areas that collectively accounted for 73 percent of U.S. higher education students. They contributed approximately $21.8 billion in tuition and $12.8 billion in other spending—representing a major services export—to those metropolitan economies over the five-year period.”
Got that? They paid full tuition and living expenses, bringing over $33 billion into the economy. And that was through 2012. In 2015, when 25% more visas were issued than in 2012, that figure rises to over $42 billion.
Two-thirds of foreign students pursuing a bachelor’s or higher degree are in science, technology, engineering, mathematics (STEM) or business, management and marketing fields, versus 48 percent of students in the United States.
Remember how tech companies claim that they depend heavily on immigrants to provide the advanced skills that they need?
Forty-five (45) percent of foreign student graduates extend their visas to work in the same metropolitan area as their college or university.
In other words, these students then go on to become the H1-B visa workers that the tech industry (and many others) claim that they need. So the “non-immigrant” nature of student visas, and the declaration of intent to return to their home country, is truly a joke. Here’s further evidence that student visas are used as the pipeline for H1-B visas:
These companies who claim that they’re dependent on immigrants for the skills they need are trying to pull the wool over your eyes. What they need are STEM graduates and they get them from American universities. They like the fact that foreign students contribute to a glut of labor that helps to keep their payroll costs suppressed. When Apple claims that, if immigrants aren’t allowed to travel freely to work in the U.S., then they might need to relocate to where they can have easier access to immigrant labor, that’s a “crock” and they know it. Go ahead, Apple, move to Yemen or Iran or Libya or one of those other countries, and let’s see how successful you can be there. What you really need are the STEM graduates of American universities. You won’t find them in those other places. But what you will find are poverty, illiteracy and oppressive governments. But you say you can do better there. So prove it. Just leave. Go ahead. Go.
There’s a mind-numbing amount of information in these links. Let’s boil it all down:
- Immigrants currently fill 1.2 million of the seats available in American universities. That’s a significant percentage of the seats available.
- Approximately three quarters of foreign students who apply are accepted. Compare that to the acceptance rate for American students at most prominent universities, where only 10% or fewer attain admission.
- Why the preference for foreign students? Because they pay full tuition, propping up the ridiculous rate of tuition increases.
- Foreign students are given preference over American students because of their ability to pay. This effectively shuts American students out, especially from STEM curricula.
- The influx of foreign students actually counts as an export of services. Can you believe that? It’s one of the tricks used by the government to draw trade dollars back into the U.S. economy and to keep our trade data from looking even worse than it does.
- University sports teams have also gotten in on the act, now recruiting foreign students through the “student” visa program, denying athletic scholarships to deserving American athletes. When it comes time for the Olympics, those athletes, trained in America, compete for their home countries, leaving the American teams thin.
- Almost half of foreign students then go on to work in America, shutting American students out of those jobs as well.
- The student visa program feeds into the H1-B visa program, which then begins to feed many of the other immigrant categories such as immediate relatives and family-sponsored preferences.
OK, remember the above list of countries that send the most students? Did you notice anything about that list? Did you notice that it includes the countries with whom America has the biggest trade deficits? That should give you a clue as to where these foreign students are getting the money they need for tuition. Their parents are getting rich on manufacturing for export to the United States. What this means is that, in addition to taking your job, they then use your money to pay for their kids to come over here and take your kids’ jobs too! Can this scheme possibly get any more outrageous?
If you’re an American student who hasn’t been able to get accepted into the school or program of your choice, the student visa program is probably the main reason. If you’re a recent graduate and find yourself now saddled with crushing student loan debt, you can blame the student visa program for propping up ridiculous tuition rates. And if you now find yourself struggling to find a job, you can once again blame the student visa program.
The student visa program is an outrage perpetrated on unsuspecting parents and students, depriving them of opportunities to help America out of its trade-created cash crisis, to help greedy universities prop up inflated tuition rates and to help corporations suppress wages with a labor glut. It has to stop. No foreign student should be admitted until every last American kid who wants a college education has gotten a seat in a university. President Trump … please … take a close look at the student visa program and rein it in.