GM’s Request for Chinese-Built Buick Envision Tariff Relief Denied by U.S.

June 7, 2019

https://www.fidelity.com/news/article/top-news/201906042147RTRSNEWSCOMBINED_KCN1T530U-OUSBS_1

This is rich.  GM actually had the nerve to ask the U.S. government for relief on the 25% tariff it now faces on the Chinese-built Buick Envision.  (See above-linked article.)  After repeatedly angering the Trump administration with plant closures in the U.S. and moving production to Mexico, did GM really expect its request to be granted?

GM, the largest U.S. automaker, argued in its request that Envision sales in China and the United States would generate funds “to invest in our U.S. manufacturing facilities and to develop the next generation of automotive technology in the United States.”

Someone at GM must have thought, “let’s anger the administration even more with a really stupid explanation.”

As mentioned in the article, the government also denied Volvo’s tariff relief request for the Chinese-built model XC60 SUV – its best seller in the U.S.

These are good examples of key points I made in my previous post.  First of all, as mentioned in the article, GM is “eating” the tariff and not passing along the extra cost to buyers.  Secondly, the article points out that the Envision, starting at about $35,000, is a mid-size SUV that competes with other such vehicles like the Jeep Grand Cherokee.  Not mentioned is that the Jeep Grand Cherokee starts at $32,000.  So much for the claim that imports provide American consumers with lower prices.

It’s nice to see that our trade policy isn’t being run by the kind of fools we’ve had in past administrations.  And it’s nice to see that sales of the Buick Envision are tanking.  Apparently, consumers who usually pay no attention to where something is made and just assume that a Buick is an American car are waking up to the fact that they come from China.  Will anyone feel sorry for laid-off Chinese auto workers when GM cuts a shift at the Chinese plant?


Obama Backs Automakers, Fails to Act on Trade Problem

March 27, 2009

http://www.reuters.com/article/politicsNews/idUSN1838682720090326?sp=true

The linked article reports on Obama’s cyber town hall meeting yesterday in which, in response to a question, he promised additional support for U.S. automakers. 

President Barack Obama said on Thursday struggling U.S. auto companies could expect new government aid if they commit to “drastic” restructuring, promising to unveil a rescue plan in coming days.

That’s the good news.  But Obama then went on to chastise the domestic automakers for focusing on “gas-guzzling SUVs.” 

Without elaborating on a bailout price tag or specific restructuring steps for Detroit manufacturers, Obama said he wanted all major players to help overhaul a business model he called unsustainable.

“I know that it is not popular to provide help … to auto companies,” he added. “If they’re not willing to make the changes and the restructurings that are necessary, then I’m not willing to have taxpayer money chase after bad money.”

Obama has long said Detroit should build more fuel-efficient vehicles rather than focus on gas-guzzling sport utility vehicles and less efficient pickups. Sales of both models have plunged and GM, Ford and Chrysler are overhauling their product lines to emphasize efficiency.

Never, ever have I heard even a peep of protest about foreign automakers’ participation in this same segment of the market.  Apparently it’s OK for the imports to build and aggressively market their own competing models of gas-guzzling SUVs, including the following:

  • Acura MDX
  • Acura RDX
  • Audi Q7
  • BMW X3
  • BMW X5
  • BMW X6
  • Honda Pilot
  • Hyundai Santa Fe
  • Hyundai Tucson
  • Hyundai Veracruz
  • Infiniti EX35
  • Infiniti FX50
  • Infiniti QX56
  • Isuzu Ascender
  • Kia Borrego
  • Kia Sorento
  • Land Rover LR2
  • Land Rover LR3
  • Land Rover Range Rover
  • Lexus GX470
  • Lexus LX570
  • Lexus RX350
  • Mazda CX7
  • Mazda CX9
  • Mercedes Benz GLK
  • Mercedes Benz GL-Class
  • Mercedes Benz M-Class
  • Mercedes Benz R-Class
  • Mitsubishi Endeavor
  • Nissan Armada
  • Nissan Mirano
  • Nissan Pathfinder
  • Nissan Xterra
  • Porsche Cayenne
  • Saab 9-7x
  • Subaru Tribeca
  • Suzuki XL7
  • Toyota 4Runner
  • Toyota FJ Cruiser
  • Toyota Highlander
  • Toyota Land Cruiser
  • Toyota Sequoia
  • VW Tiguan
  • VW Touareg
  • Volvo XC60
  • Volvo XC90

So now our domestic automakers will be forced by the government to abandon this segment of the market, awarding it completely to imports.  Obviously, the executives at GM and Chrysler have felt compelled to keep their mouths shut when they see Obama and his auto task force arrive at such a sophomoric analysis of the domestic automakers’ problems.

But worst of all (not reported in this article, but receiving broad coverage in the Detroit area media), were Obama’s statements immediately following the above quotes.  The reason that he sees the domestic automakers’ business model as unsustainable, and I’m paraphrasing here, is that “foreign competition is here to stay.”  He sees no need to do anything about the idiotic trade policies that have destroyed the domestic auto industry and the entire manufacturing sector of our economy.  In his mind (which is to say in the minds of the auto task force, led by free trade advocate Larry Summers), the answer is to more fully engage in the race to the bottom.  That is, cut workers’ pay and benefits.  Eliminate jobs.  Close factories. 

Unfortunately, none of those actions will make one bit of difference in making the domestic auto industry more viable and robust.  Foreign automakers will simply match them cut-for-cut to maintain and even boost their market share.  We keep inviting in more foreign automakers (soon India’s Tata Motors, China’s Chery Automotive, Fiat and Renault will enter the fray) without getting any access to equivalent markets in return.  How the auto task force can be so blind to this issue, allowing our domestic industry to be painted into an ever-tighter corner, is beyond me. 

Thus far, in violation of his promises to the American people, the Obama Administration has done absolutely nothing about unfair, lopsided trade deals.  Even the imposition of tariffs by Mexico on American goods has been met with silence and indifference.  Trade ministers around the world must grab their bellies and roll in the aisle with laughter every time our economic leaders and trade negotiators leave town.  In the global trade community, the U.S. is the village idiot.