The Bureau of Labor Statistics yesterday released its employment report for the month of March. The headline jobs number was weak. “Only” 98,000 jobs were added in March – about half of what was expected. But unemployment dropped by two tenths (a fairly big drop) to 4.5%. The data underlying the unemployment figure was quite strong. The “employment level” (the number of people reporting being employed in the household survey portion of the report) rose by 472,000 in March. (It rose by 447,000 in February.) And the labor force grew by 145,000 – outpacing the growth in the general population for the fourth month in a row.
Last month, Trump hailed the strong February employment report as “real,” as opposed to the “fake” reports produced by the Obama administration. (The Obama administration did lean heavily on claims of a shrinking labor force to prop up its unemployment figures.) Was that claim just bluster or has the reporting methodology actually changed for the better? It’s two early to tell but, at least for the second month in a row, the BLS claims that the labor force grew (as it actually does, of course) and the numbers seem plausible. Time will tell.
Per capita employment (the employment level divided by the population) climbed above 47% for the first time since November, 2008. (Here’s the chart: Per Capita Employment.) The “detachment from reality index” – my measure of how much the unemployment figures were distorted by the “mysteriously vanishing labor force” tactic used by the Obama administration – fell to its lowest level since January, 2013. (Here’s the chart: Detachment from Reality Index.)
This is great news, but it has more to do with a burst of confidence among consumers (likely driven by a burst of confidence among investors which has driven the stock market higher) in the wake of Trump’s election. The fundamentals of the economy haven’t changed. The trade deficit is as bad as ever. And interest rates are on the rise which will pull the economy down if Trump isn’t able to make headway with tax and trade reforms. And the jump in stocks that have propelled the economy has already stalled, now waiting to see if expectations of Trump policies actually materialize.
I hope that what appears to be honesty with the factors that make up the employment report (based on a scant two months’ of data) continues. But without the “border tax” that Trump promised, the good numbers won’t.
By the way, for some time now, the Federal Reserve and others have been proclaiming the economy to be at full employment. If that were true, then how does the economy continue to add jobs at a faster rate than the growth in the labor force, and how does the unemployment rate continue to fall? It’s because they were all sucked in by the “detached from reality” employment reports produced by the Obama administration. The fact is that an honest reading of unemployment (one that grew the labor force in proportion to population growth) has unemployment at 7.3% – nowhere even remotely close to “full employment.”