Obama Transitions to Caretaker President


As evidenced by the State of the Union address last night, Obama has chosen to respond to falling poll numbers and rising anger among the electorate by taking the safe route and morphing into yet another caretaker president.  Aside from waxing eloquent in his opening and closing remarks about the historic challenges we face, he sounded exactly like George Bush and every president preceding him for the past two generations, offering a littany of tax cuts and credits to get the economy moving in the right direction, while closing with vows to reduce the budget deficit. 

“Change we can believe in” is dead.  There were still echoes of the campaign trail when he spoke of eliminating tax breaks for companies who outsource jobs, enforcing trade deals, health care reform, green jobs and an energy policy, but there was no conviction in his voice and everyone watching knew that it was merely nostalgic rhetoric.  The efficacy of the speech was best summed up in one moment when, after speaking at length about fiscal restraint and reining in the budget deficit, he concluded with “but that will have to wait till next year,” deservedly drawing loud guffaws from the Republican side of the room. 

Most disappointing of all was his comments on trade.  Contrary to his campaign promise to stand firm against any more free trade deals that have devastated our manufacturing sector, he now supports conclusion of the Doha round of World Trade Organization talks, with its agenda of opening another artery in America’s economy upon which more parasitic economies will feed.  And his vow to double exports by opening new markets is nothing more than a retreat into the same dumb trade policy that has amassed a trade deficit of ten trillion dollars while simultaneously dismantling our manufacturing sector over the past three decades.  We’ll “open new markets.”  Right.  That means opening our market first,  in return for  markets so badly stunted by low per capita consumption that an even bigger trade deficit is the only possible outcome.  This part of the speech was a slap in the face to every voter, like me, who put faith in Obama’s promises to reduce the trade deficit and bring manufacturing jobs home.

The practitioners of old-school, 18th century economics have won the day again.  A few more tax breaks here.  Sprinkle in some token cost cuts there.  Pump up the economy with immigration and population growth.  Drill, baby, drill.  “Spin, baby, spin.”  (The unspoken platitude to the green crowd.)  Boost exports.  Pay no mind to those nuisance imports.  Crank up the printing press at the mint.  Don’t rock the boat.  Everything will be fine.  This is our future.  We now have another caretaker to see to it.

Just one problem.  This isn’t the middle of the 20th century.  Those approaches have culminated in economic ruin.  Continue on this path and you can take one of two outcomes to the bank:  far worse unemployment or a $20 trillion national debt in ten years that collapses our economy, perhaps forever.  Obama has chosen the well-worn path and crossed his fingers in the hope that it doesn’t happen on his watch.

10 Responses to Obama Transitions to Caretaker President

  1. Mark Hall says:

    “Caretaker” as in “put-them-in-the-ground” caretaker?

  2. Mark Hall says:


    It still looks like “Yellow” paint to me.

    I say “Yellow”, you say “Red”

    Let’s compromise!

    Let’s call it “Yeller” as in “Obama Yeller”.

    See there, we just created something (a new paint color).

    Which is something they can’t seem to do in Washington.

  3. Mark Hall says:

    They must be taking their lead from the drug companies.

    Analysis, Development, Trial Period, Market Analysis & Deployment usually takes 7-10 years.

    And, if you get it wrong, another 7-10 years.

  4. Robert says:


    Why are the people in power so oblivious to seeking out real solutions along the lines of your book? Could there be some other reason the government continues pushing policies that obviously will not work? It just amazes me as to the stupidity of it all. Perhaps it is just basic human nature to avoid real change and continue with the familiar until it is no longer possible.

    • Pete Murphy says:

      Robert, I’m afraid it boils down to economics. The president is following the advice of his economists, still mired in 18th century thinking about perpetual growth. I’m more convinced than ever that it’s the field of economics that needs to be changed before we’ll ever see politicians change course.

  5. mtnmike says:

    Nice post today Pete. In my opinion you nailed step 3 in our presidents plan, “And then, there will be a miracle.”

    He totally glossed over immigration, ignored energy depletion, ignored global waning food production, ignored the fact that any green energy manufacturing would be immediately moved to the world’s cheapest factory floors, and he was extremely divisive in much of his content.

    Other than that, I think the Rah-Rah aspect and the gullibility index deserve high marks.

    • Pete Murphy says:

      I was actually glad to hear immigration pushed to the back of the speech, where he spoke of the need for more border security but, if I recall correctly, didn’t actually advocate a new push for immigration “reform.” Much to the dismay of the immigration reform (euphemism for amnesty for illegals) movement, this issue is clearly so far down on the agenda that it’ll never see the light of day.

  6. Mark Hall says:

    Today’s headline: “First-time jobless claims drop less than expected”

    We keep hearing the phrases:

    “Dropped more than expected”
    “Rose more than expected”
    “Dropped Unexpectedly”
    “Rose Unexpectedly”

    When can we expect to start hearing these phrases?

    “Dropped 10% below Outlined Target”
    “Rose 15% more than Established Goal”

    You have to have “Established Goals” & “Outlined Targets” to improve.

    Then “We Must” will replace “We Would Like”, “We Need” and “We Want”.

    It’s called “ACCOUNTABILITY”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: